This article has Open Peer Review reports available.
Health inequalities: an analysis of hospitalizations with respect to migrant status, gender and geographical area
- Chiara de Waure†1Email author,
- Stefania Bruno†1,
- Giuseppe Furia1,
- Luca Di Sciullo†2,
- Serena Carovillano1,
- Maria Lucia Specchia†1,
- Salvatore Geraci†3 and
- Walter Ricciardi†1
© de Waure et al.; licensee BioMed Central. 2015
Received: 3 June 2014
Accepted: 17 November 2014
Published: 7 February 2015
The quality of care includes several aspects which may be influenced by social-economic status.
This study analyzes hospitalizations for several conditions, such as chronic diseases, cancer and appendectomy, in Italians and immigrant people living in Italy with the aim to evaluate possible inequalities in the quality of health care services due to migrant status, gender and geographical macro-areas (Northern, Central, Southern Italy).
The data source of hospital discharges for stroke, myocardial infarction, chronic liver disease, cervical cancer, mastectomy and appendectomy was the Ministry of Health. ICD 9 codes were used for data collection. Crude and standardized hospitalization rates per 100.000 were calculated. Italian resident population and an estimate of immigrants living in Italy were used as denominators while standardization was done with respect to the European population. The data we used covers the 2006–2008 period.
Immigrants showed significantly higher hospitalization rates for stroke, cervical cancer and appendectomy and significantly lower hospitalization rates for chronic liver diseases and mastectomy. Males showed significantly higher hospitalization rates than females for myocardial infarction, chronic liver diseases and appendectomy. Notwithstanding, differences related to migrant status and gender varied according to geographical macro-area. With respect to that, Southern Italy showed significantly higher hospitalization rates for stroke, myocardial infarction and chronic liver diseases and significantly lower hospitalization rates for mastectomy and appendectomy.
The results of this study may reflect inequalities in the quality of health care, in particular in primary and secondary prevention, access to specialized care and inappropriateness, due to migrant status and gender. Also, differences between macro-areas suggest heterogeneities in the integration policies and the promotion of immigrants’ health. Research should be endorsed in this field in order to further describe inequalities and their reasons and in the light of supporting policies development.
Health inequalities are systematic differences in health status between groups of people belonging to different socioeconomic positions within countries and between countries. They may be considered inequities if they are unfair and avoidable. The absence of equity determines the deterioration of health conditions, especially in socially disadvantaged groups, resulting in a social gradient of health [1,2].
Social determinants of health play an important role in determining inequalities both in the developmental phase of life [3,4] and in adulthood. Regarding the latter, limitations/lack of access to social goods, which may be associated to gender and race/ethnicity, may have an impact on health. In particular, in recent years, inequalities due to migrant status have been paid a growing interest and attention both in the literature and in declarations released by international political-institutional organizations . In September 2007, the Conference “Health and Migration in the EU: better health for all in an inclusive society” established the importance of migrants’ universal access to care as an essential element for social, economic and political development of countries as well as for the promotion of human rights. Indeed, the promotion of integration and of an equal access to care is an urgent instance in Public Health . The same “Bratislava Declaration on health, human rights and migration”  established that health interventions for migrants, including Public Health ones, should be implemented in order to promote the well-being of all people and the integration of migrants. In accordance to this, in March 2011, the European Parliament approved a resolution on reducing health inequalities in the European Union , and the Member States were invited to address inequalities in access to health care for undocumented immigrants, pregnant women and children. It was emphasized that “Health inequalities are not only the result of a multitude of economic, environmental or lifestyle factors, but they also depend on access to health care services”. Nevertheless the Member States have not yet achieved a common direction about integration policies for migrants, although the right to health is profoundly rooted, as enshrined in the Declaration of Alma Ata which incorporates a social dimension in governmental policies, with particular attention to disadvantaged groups such as women, elderly people, irregular immigrants, refugees and asylum seekers .
In Italy, over the last 30 years, the presence of non-Italian citizens has increased. In 2011 around 4,000,000 individuals were regularly present in Italy, which represented 8,6% of the national population, compared to a European average of 6,6%. An heterogeneity of immigrant distribution in the country may be appreciated with more than half of immigrants living in North, followed by Central and Southern Italy [10,11]. Immigrants are a young population, represented about half by women, with a significant presence of minors (about one million). They come from over 190 different countries. In particular, 27,4% come from countries that are part of the European Union, 23,4% from non-Community European Countries, 22,1% from Africa, 18,8% from Asia, 8,3% from America and the remaining from Oceania [12,13].
Since the 1990s, Italian national health policies and laws allow regular non-Italian citizens the access to the National Health Service (NHS). Furthermore, the delivery of care is provided also to those who are temporarily irregular. Nevertheless the heterogeneity of health policies adopted by individual regions determines inequalities in the availability of services [14,15] and phenomena, such as high rates of voluntary interruption of pregnancy , which deserve more attention to integration policies. With this respect, the knowledge of the current access to health care and of the quality of health services is fundamental in order to support the decision-making process.
This study analyzes hospitalizations for several conditions, such as chronic diseases, cancer and appendectomy, in Italians and immigrant people living in Italy. The final aim is to allow evaluating potential differences in the quality of health care services, which is made up of several aspects, among which access to healthcare , due to migrant status as well as to gender and geographical area. The new aspects of this cross-sectional study are the assessment of health inequalities through the analysis of hospitalization data, as a proxy of the quality of health care services, and the attempt to release an estimate of immigrants’ hospitalization rate which takes into account irregular people also.
Study design and population
cervical cancer and mastectomy as an indicator of the impact of both primary and secondary preventive initiatives ,
Indicators grouped by dimensions and ICD 9 CM codes
ICD 9 CM
434.01, 434.11, 434.91, 431
Cirrhosis and chronic liver diseases
070.22, 070.23, 070.32, 070.33
070.44, 070.54, 571.0, 571.2, 571.40, 571.41, 571.49
85.23, 85.4, 85.22
ISTAT data on regular immigrant population,
valid permits of residence delivered by the Ministry of Internal Affairs each year,
foreign minors born in Italy each year,
accepted requests for legal residence permit each year,
a 10% of underestimation of irregular people living in Italy provided by the Foundation for Initiatives and Studies on Multi-Ethnicity.
Statistical elaboration of data
Northern Italy: Emilia-Romagna, Friuli-Venezia Giulia, Liguria, Lombardia, Piemonte, Trentino-Alto Adige, Valle d’Aosta and Veneto,
Central Italy: Lazio, Marche, Toscana and Umbria,
Southern Italy: Abruzzo, Basilicata, Calabria, Campania, Molise, Puglia, Sicilia and Sardegna.
Ti = crude rate for each age class
Ni = size of the reference population in each age class
ni = size of the study population in each age class
K = multiplication factor (100.000)
The analysis of data was done descriptively with respect to the following dimensions: time differences due to migrant status, gender and geographical area.
Total discharges - standardized hospitalization rates for European population (per 100.000), with 95% CI, stratified for macro-area and year
27076,2 (27029,0- 27123,4)
Chronic diseases - standardized hospitalization rates for European population (per 100.000), with 95% CI, stratified for macro-area and year
Cirrhosis and chronic liver diseases
Cancers - standardized hospitalization rates for European population (per 100.000), with 95% CI, stratified for macro-area and year
Appendectomy - standardized hospitalization rates for European population (per 100.000), with 95% CI, stratified for macro-area and year
A decrease in hospitalization rates for appendectomy was found in all macro-areas, in both genders and citizenships. Notwithstanding, the decrease was significant only for Italians in Northern and Southern Regions.
Details on differences linked to migrant status, gender and geographical macro-area are as follows.
Differences related to migrant status
Immigrants showed significantly higher hospitalization rates for stroke as compared to Italians in Southern Italy. Regarding myocardial infarction, immigrants had generally lower rates if compared to Italians even though differences were not significant. With regard to chronic liver diseases, hospitalization rates of immigrants were significantly lower than Italians in Northern and Southern Italy.
Hospitalization rates for mastectomy were generally lower for immigrants, even though differences were significant only in Northern Italy. In contrast, cervical cancer hospitalization rates were generally higher among immigrants, in some cases more than two-fold. Nonetheless, differences were statistically significant in Southern Italy only.
Finally, immigrants had significantly higher hospitalization rates than Italians for appendectomy.
Differences related to gender
With regards to gender, stroke hospitalization rates were similar in males and females. As for myocardial infarction, males had significantly higher hospitalization rates than females. This was verified also for chronic liver diseases, but in Italians only. For appendectomy, males had generally higher rates than females but differences did not reach the significance but for Southern Italy.
Differences related to geographical macro-areas
Hospitalization rates for stroke, myocardial infarction and chronic liver diseases were significantly lower in Northern Italy than Southern Italy.
On the contrary, hospitalization rates for mastectomy were higher in Northern Italy for Italians only whilst hospitalization rates for cervical cancer did not show significant trends.
With respect to appendectomy, significantly higher rates were observed in Northern Italy for Italians (Table 5).
Differences between Central and Northern/Southern Italy were more difficult to assess because of the high variability of data in Central Italy.
This work was primarily aimed at investigating differences in the quality of health care likely to be associated to migrant status, gender and geographical macro-area. At the same time, the study investigated time trends.
With respect to the latter, a general decrease in total as well as disease-specific hospitalization rates was observed. This result is quite important and could suggest an improvement in quality of care. In particular, a better control of inappropriateness, which is a dimension of quality , was highlighted by results. Furthermore, the significant reduction in hospitalization for chronic liver diseases and mastectomy may underline an improvement of primary and secondary prevention interventions over time. Notwithstanding, the decrease of hospitalization rates over time may also be the result of changes in the Italian NHS due to economic constraints which led to a reduction of total number of hospital beds (from 3,3 to 3,0 per 1.000 inhabitants from 2004 to 2008 ).
With respect to migrant status, important differences resulted from the analysis. First of all, it should be observed that total hospitalization rates were higher for Italians than immigrants. This may suggest constraints, in particular, in the access to health services as well as differences in the health status between Italians and immigrants. In fact, literature shows that immigrants are often healthier than native-born .
Nevertheless, looking at specific diseases, peculiarities may be appreciated. In fact, summarizing results yielded by the study, immigrants showed higher rates of hospitalizations with regard to stroke, cervical cancer and appendectomy with some differences with respect to geographical area. These results may hide a deficiency in primary and secondary prevention (e.g. lack/inefficacy of educational campaigns in immigrants; low access to cervical cancer screening by immigrant women). In particular, as far as stroke is concerned, the limited access to preventive medicine interventions, reported also in other studies on “migrant health status” , may result in an unequal distribution of risk factors for cardiovascular diseases, such as smoking, stress, unhealthy diet and hypertension. A higher incidence of cardiovascular diseases was also observed in immigrant population in comparison to native-born in Denmark. Interestingly, the differences between immigrant and Danish population were reduced after the adjustment for socio-economic factors such as income, employment, housing and education . With respect to cervical cancer, the higher hospitalization rates of immigrant women may be probably due to a greater exposure to Human Papilloma Virus infection [28,29] and to a limited access to screening [30-33]. Finally, regarding appendectomy, the higher hospitalizations rates of immigrants may underline a greater risk for inappropriateness due to a lower level of quality of care. In fact, the datum could be more likely attributed to unnecessary interventions instead of a higher occurrence of appendicitis among immigrants since the disease is reported to be lower in immigrants mainly because of factors which depend on dietary habits .
On the contrary, hospitalization rates were lower for immigrants than Italians with respect to chronic liver diseases and mastectomy with some differences due to geographical area. This may suggest a more attention paid in the primary care of liver chronic conditions as well as cancer in Italians than immigrants. In particular, with respect to mastectomy, higher hospitalization rates of Italians may be due to the early detection of cancer which is linked to the access to screening programs . Alongside, it should be also observed that some risk factors for breast cancer, such as nulliparity, oral contraceptives use and artificial feeding, may be unequally distributed among immigrants and Italians so justifying in part results. The higher rates of hospitalizations for chronic liver diseases of Italians may be the indication of an easier access, which is also an aspect of healthcare quality, to specialized care by Italians than immigrants. With this respect, a limited access of immigrants to diagnostic and treatment services for hepatitis has been evidenced by Fasano M. et al. . Furthermore the above-mentioned “healthy migrant effect”  may also play a role with respect to chronic liver diseases.
As far as gender differences are concerned, disease-specific hospitalization rates were generally higher in males than females. This result could suggest that women may face more barriers in the access to health services.
Finally, with respect to geographic trend, a North–South gradient was shown, with the highest rates of hospitalization in the Southern Italy for both immigrants and Italians, indicating a possible unequal distribution of socio-economic factors as well as inequalities in the quality of health care.
In particular, as far as chronic diseases are concerned, Southern Italy showed the highest hospitalization rates. On the other hand, Northern Italy was characterized by higher rates of hospitalizations for mastectomy and appendectomy in Italians. These differences should be carefully considered and better investigated with respect to their causes which may be related to the health care organization outside the hospitals as well as to local health and other policies.
The results which were released by this study could be different if we considered immigrants’ country of origin. Notwithstanding, in the comparison between macro-areas, results may be considered not biased because 55-60% of immigrants are from Europe and 15-20% from Africa in either Northern, Central and Southern Italy. In particular, around 40% of immigrants in all areas are from Romania, Albania and Morocco .
This study has some limitations. First of all, it relies only on few indicators which were considered as a proxy of the quality of health care services. As a consequence, the analysis cannot be considered thorough with respect to the different levels of health care. Furthermore, it did not take into consideration outcome indicators which are more valuable in the evaluation of the performance of health care systems. Another limitation is represented by the use of citizenship as a criterion to establish migrant status even though it should be considered more reliable than the birth place which is the alternative way used in the literature to define the migrant status. Notwithstanding, misclassification of some cases cannot be excluded also because of the use of administrative data flows. With respect to this last aspect, it should be added that administrative data flows may present missing data as well as mistakes which may not be controlled.
On the other hand, some strengths may be seen. The analysis was carried out at national level, being quite useful for national health care planning. Furthermore, it attempted to describe the quality of health care provided to immigrant population. With this respect, in contrast to other analysis which were performed on official statistics, our study relied on a new estimate of immigrant population which took into consideration also people living irregularly in our country. Indeed, generalizability of results may be considered quite good within the national context, albeit it cannot be stated the same outside Italy because of different health and immigration policies. Furthermore, the comparison of hospitalization rates between men and women as well as Italians and immigrants may be considered unbiased because of the standardization process which allowed controlling for age.
In conclusion, on the basis of the evidence also, which suggests that some barriers, such as language difficulties, a poor awareness of health status and the lack of economic resources, may influence the quality of provided healthcare services , implications for both research and policy may be recognized. In particular, research should be promoted in the field of the assessment of reasons behind inequalities in order to support the development of tailored interventions and policies for the reduction of differences in the quality of health care.
In order to carry out the study anonymous aggregated data were collected from routinely administrative databases. This ensured patients’ privacy and allowed not requiring patients’ personal informed consent. For this reason, the approval of the ethics committee was not requested.
We acknowledge the Ministry of Health for the data collection and Dr. Ljupco Efremov for his contribution to this manuscript.
- World Health Organization. Social determinants of health. [http://www.who.int/social_determinants/thecommission/finalreport/key_concepts/en/]
- Whitehead M. The concepts and principles of equity in health. Int J Health Serv. 1992;22:429–45.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Kuh D, Ben-Shlomo Y, Lynch J, Hallqvist J, Power C. Life course epidemiology. J Epidemiol Community Health. 2003;57:778–83.View ArticlePubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar
- Wilkinson R. Unhealthy Societies: the afflictions of inequality. London-New York: Routledge; 1996.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Marceca M, Geraci S, Baglio G. Immigrants’ health protection: political, institutional and social perspectives at international and Italian level. Ital J Public Health. 2012;9:2427–7498.Google Scholar
- International Organization for Migration (IOM). Migration Health: Better Health for all in Europe - Final Report. Brussels: IOM Migration Health department; 2009.Google Scholar
- Bratislava Declaration on health. Human rights and migration, 8th Conference of European Health Ministers. People on the Move: Human Rights and Challenges for Health Care Systems. Bratislava: Council of Europe; 2007.Google Scholar
- European Parliament Resolution of 8 March 2011 on the reduction of health inequalities in EU (2010/2089(INI)). Reduction of health inequalities. [http://www.europarl.europa.eu/sides/getDoc.do?type=TA&reference=P7-TA-2011-0081&language=EN]
- United Nations. The universal declaration of human rights. [http://www.un.org/en/documents/udhr/]
- Geraci S, Baglio G. Salute Degli Immigrati. In: Rapporto Osservasalute 2013, Chapter 13. 11th ed. Rome: Prex; 2014.Google Scholar
- Eurostat. Statistiche sulle migrazioni internazionali e sulle popolazioni di origine straniera. 2012. [http//epp.eurostat.ec.europa.eu/statistics_explained/index.php/Migration_and_migrant_population_statistics/it]
- Caritas e Migrantes. Dossier Statistico Immigrazione 2012, 22° report. Centro Studi e Ricerche IDOS; 2012.Google Scholar
- Italian National Institute of Statistics. I cittadini non comunitari regolarmente soggiornanti. Rome; 2012 [http://www.istat.it/it/archivio/67648]
- Bonciani M, Geraci S, Martinelli B. La salute degli immigrati nelle politiche sanitarie regionali. [http://www.saluteinternazionale.info/2011/04/la-salute-degli-immigrati-nelle-politiche-sanitarie-regionali/]
- Osservatorio Epidemiologico sulle Diseguaglianze/ARS Marche. Immigrati e servizi sanitari in Italia: le risposte dei sistemi sanitari regionali. [http://www.ccm-network.it/documenti_Ccm/prg_area5/Prg_5_Immigrati_report.pdf]
- Donabedian A. Explorations in Quality Assessment and Monitoring Vol. 1. The Definition of Quality and Approaches to Its Assessment. Ann Arbor, MI: Health Administration Press; 1980.Google Scholar
- Soljak M, Calderon-Larrañaga A, Sharma P, Cecil E, Bell D, Abi-Aad G, et al. Does higher quality primary health care reduce stroke admissions? A national cross-sectional study. Br J Gen Pract. 2011;61:593.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Sims M, Maxwell R, Bauld L, Gilmore A. Short term impact of smoke-free legislation in England: retrospective analysis of hospital admissions for myocardial infarction. BMJ. 2010;340:c2161.View ArticlePubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar
- Giannoni M, Casucci P, Bini S, Federici S, Ismail Z, Briziarelli L. Immigrati e Servizio Sanitario Regionale: Equità nell’accesso ai Servizi e valutazione della performance. AUS; 2010.Google Scholar
- Ministero della Salute. Direzione generale della programmazione sanitaria, dei livelli di assistenza e dei principi etici di sistema, Ufficio VI, Programma Operativo Appropriatezza: Studio e sperimentazione di indicatori per determinare il grado di appropriatezza delle prestazioni di ricovero dovute a carenze delle altre forme di assistenza. Rome: Ministero della Salute; 2011.Google Scholar
- Allin S, Masseria C, Sorenson C, Papanicolas I, Mossialos E. Measuring Inequalities in Access to Health Care. A Review of the Indices. Brussels, Belgium: European Commission; 2007.Google Scholar
- Materia E, Rossi L, Cacciani L. L’appropriatezza dei ricoveri dei cittadini stranieri nel Lazio. In: Rapporto sull’assistenza ospedaliera a cittadini stranieri nel lazio. Chapter 6. Rome: ASP Lazio; 2000.Google Scholar
- Armitage P, Berry G. Statistical Methods in Medical Research. 3rd ed. Oxford: Blackwell Scientific Publications; 1994.Google Scholar
- Ministero della Salute. Direzione Generale Del Sistema Informativo. Ufficio Di Direzione Statistica. Annuario Statistico del Servizio Sanitario Nazionale. 2008. [http://www.salute.gov.it/imgs/C_17_pubblicazioni_1488_allegato.pdf]
- Kennedy S, McDonald JT, Biddle N. The Healthy Immigrant Effect and Immigrant Selection: Evidence from Four Countries, SEDAP Research Paper No. 164. 2006.Google Scholar
- De Luca G, Ponzo M, Andrés AR. Health care utilization by immigrants in Italy. Int J Health Care Finance Econ. 2013;13:1–31.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Hempler NF, Larsen FB, Nielsen SS, Diderichsen F, Andreasen AH, Jørgensen T. A registry-based follow-up study, comparing the incidence of cardiovascular disease in native Danes and immigrants born in Turkey, Pakistan and the former Yugoslavia: do social inequalities play a role? BMC Public Health. 2011;11:662.View ArticlePubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar
- Mariani L, Morrone A, Franco G, Vocaturo A, Benevolo M, Malandino F, et al. Prevalenza dell’HPV nella popolazione migrante. Turin: 81° Congresso Nazionale SIDeMaST; 2006.Google Scholar
- Chiaradia G, La Torre G, Ricciardi W. Epidemiologia dell’infezione da HPV e delle malattie correlate. Ital J Public Health. 2007;4:2.Google Scholar
- Gruppo Italiano Screening del Cervicocarcinoma (GISCi). Survey Gisci Sulle Migranti Nei Programmi Di Screening Cervicale. 2014. [http://www.gisci.it/documenti/documenti_gisci/GISCI-documenti-migranti-2014.pdf]
- Norredam M, Nielsen SS, Krasnik A. Migrants’ utilization of somatic healthcare services in Europe-a systematic review. Eur J Public Health. 2010;20:555–63.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Rondet C, Lapostolle A, Soler M, Grillo F, Parizot I, Chauvin P. Are immigrants and nationals born to immigrants at higher risk for delayed or no lifetime breast and cervical cancer screening? The results from a population-based survey in Paris Metropolitan area in 2010. PLoS ONE. 2014;22:9.Google Scholar
- Italian National Institute of Statistics. Salute e ricorso ai servizi sanitari della popolazione straniera residente in Italia. Rome: ISTAT; 2005 [http://www3.istat.it/salastampa/comunicati/non_calendario/20081211_00/testointegrale20081211.pdf]Google Scholar
- Fasano M, Saracino A, Carosi G, Mazzotta F, Marino N, Sagnelli E, et al. Hepatitis B and immigrants: a SIMIT multicenter cross-sectional study. Infection. 2013;41:53–9.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Affronti M, Affronti A, Pagano S, Soresi M, Giannitrapani L, Valenti M, et al. The health of irregular and illegal immigrants: analysis of day-hospital admissions in a department of migration medicine. Intern Emerg Med. 2013;8:561–6.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Italian National Institute of Statistics. Demografia in cifre. La rilevazione sui bilanci demografici dei cittadini stranieri. Rome; 2008. [http://demo.istat.it/altridati/rilbilstra/]
- Priebe S, Sandhu S, Dias S, Gaddini A, Greacen T, Ioannidis E, et al. Good practice in health care for migrants: views and experiences of care professionals in 16 European countries. BMC Public Health. 2011;11:187.View ArticlePubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar
This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly credited. The Creative Commons Public Domain Dedication waiver (http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/) applies to the data made available in this article, unless otherwise stated.